Targum vs DeepL

Leading with Light

Leading with Light, Doron Amitai Libshtein

Translation score

Three AI readers who know Hebrew read the Hebrew original, the author’s voice notes and both translations, without knowing which was which, and scored each as a translation. A 10 means this is how the author would have written the book in English.

  • Targum8.7
  • DeepL5.7

3 of these 3 readers preferred Targum.

Scores by criterion
TargumDeepL
Meaning8.77.3
Facts8.05.7
Author’s voice8.76.3
Localization8.35.3
Natural English8.76.3

Reading score

Three other AI readers saw only the two English versions and scored each as a book in English, where a 10 is a first-rate published book of its kind. Read the same way, three classic American bestsellers (Babbitt, Main Street and The Age of Innocence) scored 8.7 to 9.0.

  • Targum8.0
  • DeepL4.3

3 of 3 AI readers preferred Targum.

Scores by criterion
TargumDeepL
Natural English8.05.3
Expressiveness7.35.0
Punch7.04.3
Idioms and expressions8.05.3
Author’s voice8.05.0
Clarity8.74.3

Green What worked in ours

Red What went wrong in the others

How we tested: the Hebrew is the excerpt on our sample page. Targum: the translation shown there, after a final editing pass (October 2026). DeepL: the DeepL API (quality model), Hebrew to American English, October 2026, paragraph by paragraph. Scores: two panels of three AI readers per book (Claude models) who didn't know which version was which.

Foreword

The Hebrew original

בבוקר ה-7 באוקטובר 2023, בשעה 07:07, נגדעו חייו של אופיר ליבשטיין בקרב בכפר עזה.

Targum

At 7:07 a.m. on October 7, 2023, Ofir Libshtein’s life was cut short in battle at Kfar Aza.

DeepL

On the morning of October 7, 2023, at 7:07 a.m., Ofir Libstein’s life was cut short in battle in Kfar Aza.

The Hebrew original

באותו יום שחור איבדנו גם את בנו ניצן, ואיתם נקטעו חייהם של אלפי ישראלים. אך בעוד חייו של אופיר הסתיימו בגיל חמישים, המורשת שהותיר אחריו היא נצחית - מורשת של מנהיגות אנושית שתמשיך להאיר את דרכנו במאה השנים הבאות ומעבר לכך.

Targum

That dark day took his son Nitzan too, and thousands of other Israelis with them. Ofir died at the age of fifty, but the legacy he left behind is timeless: a legacy of Humane Leadership that will continue to illuminate our path for generations to come.

DeepL

On that dark day, we also lost his son Nitzan, and along with them, the lives of thousands of Israelis were cut short. But while Ofir’s life ended at the age of fifty, the legacy he left behind is eternal—a legacy of human leadership that will continue to light our path for the next hundred years and beyond.

The Hebrew original

ספר זה אינו ביוגרפיה. זהו מסמך חי המתעד את ׳דרך אופיר - מנהיגות אנושית׳ - גישה ייחודית למנהיגות שמציבה את האדם במרכז. אופיר ליבשטיין לא היה מנהיג רגיל. הוא היה אדם שראה את האנושיות בכל אחד, ידע להקשיב באמת, והאמין בכל ליבו שהדרך הנכונה להוביל היא דרך חיבור אמיתי לאנשים.

Targum

This book is not a biography. It is a living record of Ofir’s Way, Humane Leadership: an approach like no other, and one that puts people at its center. Ofir Libshtein was no ordinary leader. He saw the humanity in every person, knew how to listen with his whole heart, and believed that the truest way to lead was through genuine human connection.

DeepL

This book is not a biography. It is a living document chronicling “Ophir’s Way—Human Leadership”—a unique approach to leadership that places the individual at the center. Ophir Libstein was no ordinary leader. He was a man who saw the humanity in everyone, knew how to truly listen, and believed with all his heart that the right way to lead is through genuine connection with people.

The Hebrew original

דרכו של אופיר התגלמה בכל תחומי חייו: כבן מסור להוריו וכאח קרוב לאחיו, כבן זוג אוהב לוורד, כאב מסור לאביב, עידן, אורי וניצן ז״ל, כראש המועצה האזורית שער הנגב וכמנהיג קהילתי שפעל ללא לאות למען תושבי האזור, תושבי המדינה והעם היהודי כולו. הוא לא ראה בתפקידיו משרה או תואר אלא שליחות של ממש. עבורו מנהיגות הייתה דרך חיים של נתינה, הקשבה ועשייה למען הזולת באשר הוא.

Targum

Ofir’s Way found expression in every part of his life: as a devoted son and a loving brother; as Vered’s beloved partner; as a dedicated father to Aviv, Idan, Uri, and the late Nitzan; as head of the Sha’ar HaNegev Regional Council; and as a community leader who worked tirelessly for the people of the region, the citizens of Israel, and the Jewish people throughout the world. He never regarded any position as a job or a title, but as a calling. For him, leadership was a way of life: giving, listening, and doing for others, whoever they were.

DeepL

Ophir’s way was embodied in every aspect of his life: as a devoted son to his parents and a close brother to his siblings; as a loving husband to Vered; as a devoted father to Aviv, Idan, Uri, and the late Nitzan; as head of the Sha’ar HaNegev Regional Council; and as a community leader who worked tirelessly for the residents of the region, the citizens of the country, and the entire Jewish people. He did not view his roles as mere positions or titles, but as a true calling. For him, leadership was a way of life centered on giving, listening, and acting on behalf of others, wherever they may be.

The Hebrew original

׳מנהיגות אנושית׳, המושג שבחרנו כדי לייצג ולהנציח את זכרו, מייצג את התפישה הערכית העמוקה שהנחתה את אופיר. זוהי גישה המשלבת חוזק וחמלה, נחישות ורגישות, ראייה רחבה ויכולת להתחבר לפרטים הקטנים ביותר. אופיר האמין שמנהיגות אמיתית צומחת מתוך חיבור עמוק לאנשים ולצורכיהם, והדרך להוביל שינוי היא באמצעות בניית אמון ויצירת קהילה חזקה ומלוכדת.

Targum

Humane Leadership, the name we chose to carry his memory forward, embodies the deep moral vision that guided him. It marries strength with compassion, determination with sensitivity, breadth of vision with attention to the smallest detail. Ofir believed that authentic leadership grows from a profound connection to people and their needs, and that lasting change begins by building trust and creating a strong, united community.

  1. What workedNatural English: attention to the smallest detail.
  2. What workedThe name is spelled one way, Ofir, throughout.
DeepL

“Human Leadership,” the concept we have chosen to represent and commemorate his memory, embodies the profound values that guided Ofir. It is an approach that combines strength and compassion, determination and sensitivity, a broad perspective and the ability to connect with even the smallest details. Ophir believed that true leadership grows out of a deep connection to people and their needs, and that the way to bring about change is by building trust and creating a strong, united community.

  1. What went wrongLiteral phrasing: in English one doesn't 'connect with' details.
  2. What went wrongThe name appears as both Ofir and Ophir, sometimes in one paragraph.
The Hebrew original

הטרגדיה של ה-7 באוקטובר 2023 שינתה את פני המדינה ואת חיינו לנצח. נדמה כי דווקא בימים אלה של כאב, אובדן וחוסר ודאות,

המורשת של אופיר מקבלת משנה תוקף. האתגרים העצומים שניצבים בפנינו כחברה מחייבים אותנו לאמץ את דרך המנהיגות האנושית שלו: דרך של איחוד, של דיאלוג, של בניית גשרים בין אנשים לקהילות.

Targum

The tragedy of October 7, 2023, changed Israel forever, and changed our lives with it. Yet it is precisely in this time of pain, loss, and uncertainty that Ofir’s legacy speaks with renewed urgency. The immense challenges before us demand the kind of Humane Leadership he practiced: a path of unity and dialogue, of building bridges between people and communities.

DeepL

The tragedy of October 7, 2023, changed the face of our country and our lives forever. It seems that precisely in these days of pain, loss, and uncertainty,

Ophir’s legacy takes on even greater significance. The immense challenges we face as a society compel us to embrace his approach to leadership: a path of unity, dialogue, and building bridges between people and communities.

The Hebrew original

׳קרן אור אופיר׳, שהוקמה להנצחת זכרו ומורשתו, וספר זה שאתם מחזיקים בידיכם, הם יותר ממחווה לאדם יקר שאיבדנו. הם כלים מעשיים להפצה ולהטמעה של דרך המנהיגות האנושית שאופיר ייצג, דרך שיכולה וצריכה להיות נר לרגלינו בבניית עתיד טוב יותר, עתיד שבו המנהיגות מדברת את שפת האנושיות והקִרבה, ומשרתת את האדם, ולא להפך. ׳קרן אור אופיר׳ הולכת לאורו, הן להנצחתו כאדם והן כממשיכה את דרכו במיזמים השונים שהגה והוציא לפועל.

Targum

The Or Ofir Foundation, established to honor his memory and continue his legacy, and the book you now hold are more than tributes to a man we loved and lost. They are practical means of sharing and putting into action the Humane Leadership Ofir embodied, a way that can and should guide us as we build a better future, one in which leadership speaks the language of humanity and closeness and serves people, never the reverse. The Or Ofir Foundation follows his light: honoring the man he was while carrying forward the initiatives he imagined and brought to life.

  1. What workedThe book's key term stays the same throughout.
  2. What workedOne name for the foundation, and 'his light' keeps the Hebrew image.
DeepL

The “Ophir Light Foundation,” established to commemorate his memory and legacy, and this book you hold in your hands, are more than a tribute to a dear person we have lost. They are practical tools for spreading and embedding the path of humanistic leadership that Ofir represented—a path that can and must guide us in building a better future, a future in which leadership speaks the language of humanity and closeness, and serves people, rather than the other way around. The “Ophir Ray Foundation” follows in his footsteps, both to honor his memory as a person and to carry on his legacy through the various initiatives he conceived and implemented.

  1. What went wrongThe book's key term shifts from Human to humanistic leadership.
  2. What went wrongThe foundation gets two different names within one paragraph.
The Hebrew original

בדפים הבאים תמצאו את סיפורו של אופיר, מסופר מפי, מפיו ומפיהם של אנשים שהכירו אותו. מתוך התבוננות במעשיו, בפועלו ובדרכי חייו יצרתי מודל מנהיגותי שמשמר את ערכיו ומאפשר לכל אדם להיות מנהיג ומשפיע.

Targum

In the pages that follow, you will encounter Ofir’s story in my voice, in his own voice, and in the voices of those who knew him. By reflecting on his actions, his work, and the way he lived, I have shaped a model of leadership that preserves his values and invites everyone to lead, and to make a difference.

DeepL

In the following pages, you will find Ophir’s story, told through my own words, his own words, and the words of those who knew him. By reflecting on his deeds, his work, and his way of life, I have created a leadership model that preserves his values and enables every person to be a leader and an influencer.

  1. What went wrong'Influencer' now suggests social media, out of place in a memorial book.
The Hebrew original

חלק מהציטוטים והמסרים שמופיעים בספר זה לא נאמרו מפי אופיר בחייו, אך כולם נבעו מהחיבור העמוק בינינו. לאורך כתיבת הספר, המשכתי לשוחח איתו בלב, בתודעה, בנשמה. הספר נוצר מתוך הקשבה לדיאלוג הפנימי בינינו, והוא משקף הן את חייו והן את נוכחותו, אשר ממשיכה להדריך אותי ואותנו, גם לאחר לכתו.

Targum

Some of the words and messages this book attributes to Ofir were never spoken by him while he was alive. All of them, however, arose from the deep bond between us. As I wrote, I continued speaking with him, in my heart, in my mind, and in my soul. This book grew from listening to that inner dialogue. It reflects both the life he lived and the presence that continues to guide me, and all of us, after his death.

DeepL

Some of the quotes and messages that appear in this book were not spoken by Ofir during his lifetime, but they all stemmed from the deep connection between us. Throughout the writing of this book, I continued to converse with him in my heart, in my mind, and in my soul. The book was created by listening to the inner dialogue between us, and it reflects both his life and his presence, which continues to guide me and all of us, even after his passing.

Want to see how your book reads in another language?

A free sample from your own manuscript, laid out as a book.

Try a free sample